A co-CEO model can bring a broader range of expertise, greater leadership capacity and better debate before major decisions. At the same time, it creates the risk of unclear accountability. Fast Company notes that a successful pair needs clearly divided areas, a shared view of strategy and an agreed process for situations in which the two CEOs disagree.
The idea of a single chief executive is treated as self-evident in most companies. Fast Company points out that successful shared-leadership models also exist. The article refers to an earlier Harvard Business Review analysis in which companies with two CEOs delivered higher average shareholder returns over the period studied than companies led by one person. That comparison alone, however, does not prove that having two CEOs caused the better performance.
The main advantage lies in capacity and diversity of perspective. A complex organization may need to address strategy, operations, customers, capital markets, technology and regulation at the same time. Two people with complementary experience can divide part of that load while also challenging each other’s thinking.
That same difference creates the main risk. If it is unclear who decides in a particular area, managers will start taking issues to whichever CEO they expect to give the more favorable answer. Instead of greater capacity, the result is double approval and political shopping for support.
The division of roles therefore has to be explicit. One CEO may, for example, be responsible for operations and finance, while the other owns product, customers and growth. Some strategic decisions remain joint. It is also important to determine in advance what happens if the pair cannot agree.
A successful arrangement requires an exceptionally high level of trust. Each CEO must be willing to accept that the other may receive public recognition or make independent decisions in the area they own. If both compete for the position of the 'real boss,' the system breaks down.
Communication into the organization must be unified. Two leaders may have a very sharp internal debate, but once a decision is made, employees need to hear the same direction. Publicly undermining the other CEO would quickly create two centers of power.
For the board, the model is also more demanding when it comes to performance evaluation and succession. It must understand precisely which decisions are joint outcomes and what each CEO is individually accountable for.
Shared leadership is therefore not a way to avoid choosing one boss. It is a distinct organizational model that needs more precise rules than the traditional setup. If roles are unclear, two CEOs can slow decisions. If they complement each other and respect the boundaries of responsibility, they can increase the company’s leadership capacity.
KEY TERMS
- Co-CEO: One of two leaders sharing the top executive role.
- Decision boundary: A predefined area of individual or shared authority.
- Dual authority: The risk that employees receive different instructions from two top leaders.
- Complementary leadership: A combination of different skills and experience in the top role.
